Advertisement
Advertisement
Home
This Week's Telecom Sked
In Brief...
The 'Network Neutrality' Issue: Recent Stories
The Digital Television Issue: Recent Stories
David Hatch: Wired In Washington
E-mail Alert
About Us
Contacts
Privacy Policy
Advertise

Dear Reader:

We wanted to let you know that, after nearly three years of operation on the World Wide Web, National Journal's Insider Update: The Telecom Act ceased publication as of January 1, 2008.

We took this step at a time when the National Journal Group is moving to increase technology coverage -- including reporting on telecommunications and broadcasting issues -- in several of its other publications. In particular, National Journal's CongressDaily -- our twice daily publication for Capitol Hill insiders -- will be adding staff in the coming weeks for this purpose.

CongressDaily will feature the kind of detailed coverage of telecom issues, both on Capitol Hill and at the Federal Communications Commission, that you are accustomed to seeing in Insider Update -- plus a lot more.

If you are interested in a trial subscription to CongressDaily, please call 800-424-2921 or e-mail us at memberships@nationaljournal.com. Thank you for your readership and support of Insider Update, and please don't hesitate to write to me at lpeck@nationaljournal.com if you have any questions or concerns.

With best regards,
Lou Peck Editor In Chief

« Wired In Washington | Main | In Brief... »

FCC Order Wades Into Net Neutrality Controversy

By David Hatch

(Thursday, March 22) The FCC waded directly into the controversy over so-called network neutrality, opening a new front in the battle over whether the federal government should regulate communications giants that dominate the high-speed Internet business.

At a public meeting, the FCC unanimously approved an inquiry exploring how companies that provide high-speed Internet service manage Web traffic, and whether consumers of such broadband service are adversely affected.

Neutrality supporters, including such Internet content firms as Google and Yahoo, insist safeguards are needed to prevent Internet service providers from acting as content gatekeepers.

But critics, including leading providers of broadband service like Verizon Communications and AT&T, say such regulation would deter investment and is unnecessary.

The FCC acted amid growing criticism of Chairman Kevin Martin, a Republican, by the newly empowered Democratic congressional majority -- some of whom have been critical of Martin's deregulatory agenda and what they perceive as his heavy-handed style.

The Senate Commerce and the House Energy and Commerce panels already have held two FCC oversight hearings, with more planned.

Dissension over Internet regulation engulfed last year's congressional debate on telecommunications law and contributed to the demise of major Senate legislation.

Disagreement over the issue also was apparent among FCC members, who appeared split along party lines.

Martin, who has repeatedly expressed skepticism about network neutrality, insisted the FCC has been vigilant in responding to concerns about anti-competitive behavior, and that the commission has shown a willingness to act and is committed to hearing all sides.

But one of the agency's two Democratic members, Michael Copps, was outspoken in advocating stringent safeguards, declaring, "I want an FCC that unconditionally states its preference for non-discrimination on the Internet."

Both Copps and the commission's other Democrat, Jonathan Adelstein, complained that an order of inquiry lacks the teeth of a rulemaking, which can result in policy changes. Adelstein said the vote in favor of an inquiry sends a message of "how low this ranks."

Republican Commissioner Robert McDowell, however, said while it is essential for the FCC to gather data, "We must also resist the temptation to impose regulations that are based mainly on theory."

Consumer groups expressed unhappiness with Thursday's action. "This bureaucratic process will delay [action] by months if not years" due to the lack of a rulemaking, a spokesman for the public advocacy group Public Knowledge said.

But AT&T and Verizon applauded the FCC move, predicting the evidence to be gathered would highlight how broadband players benefit consumers.


Copyright 2007 by National Journal Group Inc.
The Watergate 600 New Hampshire Ave., NW Washington, DC 20037
202-739-8400 fax 202-833-8069
National Journal's Insider Update is an Atlantic Media publication.