Advertisement
Advertisement
Home
This Week's Telecom Sked
In Brief...
The 'Network Neutrality' Issue: Recent Stories
The Digital Television Issue: Recent Stories
David Hatch: Wired In Washington
E-mail Alert
About Us
Contacts
Privacy Policy
Advertise

Dear Reader:

We wanted to let you know that, after nearly three years of operation on the World Wide Web, National Journal's Insider Update: The Telecom Act ceased publication as of January 1, 2008.

We took this step at a time when the National Journal Group is moving to increase technology coverage -- including reporting on telecommunications and broadcasting issues -- in several of its other publications. In particular, National Journal's CongressDaily -- our twice daily publication for Capitol Hill insiders -- will be adding staff in the coming weeks for this purpose.

CongressDaily will feature the kind of detailed coverage of telecom issues, both on Capitol Hill and at the Federal Communications Commission, that you are accustomed to seeing in Insider Update -- plus a lot more.

If you are interested in a trial subscription to CongressDaily, please call 800-424-2921 or e-mail us at memberships@nationaljournal.com. Thank you for your readership and support of Insider Update, and please don't hesitate to write to me at lpeck@nationaljournal.com if you have any questions or concerns.

With best regards,
Lou Peck Editor In Chief

« Study: Rhode Island Is Fastest State Online | Main | Local Officials Optimistic About Franchising »

Senators Skeptical Of TV Violence Limits

By David Hatch

(Tuesday, June 26) Efforts by Sen. John (Jay) Rockefeller, D-W.Va., to restrict gratuitously violent television content hit several roadblocks in the committee he hopes will pass legislation he is drafting on the subject.

At a hearing before the Senate Commerce Committee, lawmakers from both parties sympathized with Rockefeller’s concerns about depictions of fictionalized brutality but cautioned that government mandates could abridge the First Amendment.

"I think we have to tread a lot softer," said Sen. Ted Stevens of Alaska, the ranking Republican on the panel, noting that programming also is available on the Internet and digital devices. "There are so many ways to get access to movies other than broadcasting and cable today," he said, emphasizing the importance of parental education and being "mindful" of the Constitution.

"It's difficult and it's complicated," Sen. John Sununu, R-N.H., said of the specter of content regulation. "There's no rule, law or regulation that can strike from the airwaves" all content that people dislike, he said.

Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., expressed a similar sentiment, noting that the appetite for violent shows remains strong. He recommended that the government better inform viewers about the v-chip and other content-blocking technologies for televisions.

But Rockefeller was undeterred, insisting that scientific studies affirm the detrimental impact of graphic images on children and that the industry "cowardly" blames parents for insufficient supervision.

On average, U.S. kids view more than 1,000 murders, rapes and assaults each year on TV screens, he said, describing violence as cheap to produce and profitable. He drew support from Sen. Byron Dorgan, D-N.D., who emphasized that broadcasters are licensed to serve the public interest.

Rockefeller spokesman Steven Broderick told reporters that the senator's bill, which would let the FCC regulate excessive violence, will be offered in July. The spokesman acknowledged that it would face legal challenges if enacted but said his boss is "totally prepared."

Harvard University professor Laurence Tribe, a constitutional scholar being paid to represent the TV and film industries, warned that Congress seeks to "sacrifice free speech on the altar of protecting children." While parental controls are not a perfect option, Tribe added, "giving the power to government is not the solution."

During the hearing, lawmakers were shown a digital videodisc of grisly TV clips compiled by the Parents Television Council. The DVD began with a junkie snorting heroin out of the bloodied intestines of a dead drug dealer. Lawmakers stopped the viewing shortly after it began.

Witnesses representing academia and watchdogs drew connections between TV violence and children's behavior, with PTC President Tim Winter noting a marked increase of violent content, especially of a sexual nature.

Pete Liguori, president of entertainment for Fox, whose network was unfavorably depicted on the DVD, said he shares lawmakers' concerns and explained that Fox takes numerous steps to advise viewers about content. Regulation, however, would have a "chilling effect" on the creative community, he stated.

FCC Chairman Kevin Martin was unable to testify because his newborn son is in intensive care. Panel Chairman Daniel Inouye, D-Hawaii, did not show due to a scheduling conflict, though he previously expressed support for Rockefeller's efforts.


Copyright 2007 by National Journal Group Inc.
The Watergate 600 New Hampshire Ave., NW Washington, DC 20037
202-739-8400 fax 202-833-8069
National Journal's Insider Update is an Atlantic Media publication.